For the 25th anniversary of beloved teen-period-drama-romance-fairy-tale-without-magic Ever After, Drew Barrymore invited her costars Melanie Lynskey and Megan Dodds to reminisce about the shoot on her talk show…in costume, obviously.

In the film, based on the story of Cinderella, Barrymore played the kind and hardworking Danielle, while Lynskey and Dodds were her “evil stepsisters.” Really, though, only Dodds’s character, Marguerite, is evil, taking after their haughty mother, Romilla (Anjelica Houston). Jacqueline, played by Lynskey, is a homie stuck in a bad family.

Megan Dodds and Melanie Lynskey, 1998

©20thCentFox/Courtesy Everett Collection

Drew Barrymore and Dougray Scott, 1998

20th Century Fox Licensing/Merchandising / Everett Collection

Dodds and Lynskey lived together while shooting the film in France, and recalled crashing their car and using broken French to ask for help. Feeling groovy, they also took topless photos in a cornfield. “Lucy Liu also took nude photos of me on Charlie’s Angels,” said Barrymore. “I guess it’s just what us girls do.”

The three women got a special surprise when Dougray Scott, who played Prince Henry, Zoomed in from out of town. Ever the royal, he dutifully wore a costume too. Drew Barrymore revealed a little behind-the-scenes movie magic, saying that as strong as a person she is “inside,” she couldn’t carry Scott on her back for the pivotal scene in which Danielle—flipping the prince-rescues-princess convention on its head—rescues Henry. Wires and harnesses made it work. Check out the reunion here: